The consequences and arguments against false memory syndrome

See Article History Alternative Titles: These pseudomemories are often quite vivid and emotionally charged, especially those representing acts of abuse or violence committed against the subject during childhood. It is not entirely clear how pseudomemories come about, but certain therapeutic practices are considered likely to reinforce and encourage their creation. Encouraged to visualize episodes of violence or abuse during therapy, clients may subsequently have difficulty separating these imaginary events from reality.

The consequences and arguments against false memory syndrome

The belief that memory of trauma can be repressed is a pervasive one throughout literature and in the popular press. But what is the evidence for a phenomenon of repression?

Despite popular misconceptions, there is little empirical support for the assumed prevalence of repression or even for the theory of repression itself.

Memory researchers, on the other hand, have repeatedly shown that memories associated with strong emotion are better recalled. If our ancestors had amnesia for something as traumatic as a lion attack, they would likely not have survived long.

The topic of "repressed and recovered memories" remains in bitter dispute. The Repressed Memory Phenomenon Questions about repression are separate from the fact that people may not remember being abused. Repression is a theory of why someone may not remember his abuse.

A major assumption about repression has been that "repressed and recovered" memories do not operate in the same way as ordinary memories. Inspired partly by the Freudian-based concept of repression posited as a natural psychological defense mechanism that serves to keep painful and traumatic memories out of awareness and partly by contemporary metaphors of the mind, a popularized interpretation of memory has emerged.

In this commonly held but inaccurate view, memory is seen as a sort of video recorder on which all events are stored. Trauma, it is argued, often causes memories to be "repressed" until a significant event or therapy technique "triggers" release and the memory is revealed.

Diagnoses related to "repressed memories" skyrocketed after these books were published. InRoseanne Barr appeared on the cover of People magazine claiming that she repressed memories of her mother and father abusing her from the time she was an infant until she was 17 years old. If repression were a physiological phenomenon, there should be references to it in the literature just as there are for other diseases.

The authors found no examples or references to repression prior to Memory Researchers Agree that Memory is Malleable Although the video recorder view of repressed and recovered memory is found in the popular media and self-help books, it is not consistent with research findings or with accepted theories of memory function.

Memories of life events may be easily altered by outside factors.

The consequences and arguments against false memory syndrome

The mind does not encode every detail of an event, but only a few salient features. Most of us have remarked on the differences in how two people remember the same event or have been struck by differences between a remembered image and a photographic image.

Both are examples of normal memory processes. In the first instance, an example of "cued memory," the memory was forgotten, but not lost to conscious recall.

False memory syndrome - Wikipedia

The second example demonstrates what memory researchers call the reconstructive nature of memory. Such remembrances, which have been the subject of extensive research, are not considered evidence that "repression" or "dissociation" occurred.

The evidence shows that strong emotions generally create unwanted and intrusive memories, as opposed to blocking them. Rarely does the amnesia cover the entire event. There is no scientific evidence that memories, if they were to be repressed, would operate by a different set of rules so that they could be stored and later recalled in pristine form.

Normal memory processes can explain why some people may forget traumatic experiences.The following articles provide critical analyses of the debate over recovered memory, integrating scientific research, addressing the misnomer “false memory,” and exploring the role of .

A special type of false allegation, the false memory syndrome, arises typically within therapy, when people report the "recovery" of childhood memories of previously unknown abuse.

The influence of practitioners' beliefs and practices in the eliciting of false "memories" and of false complaints has come under particular criticism. Jul 04,  · The focus of this review is to consider the consequences of false memories in legal proceedings, examining the nature of false memory with a look at lessons from these cases and their modern day consequences.

Elizabeth Loftus update on repressed memory controversy. American Psychologist , 48, A false memory of abuse.

desperate search for one dimensional solutions to multidimensional problems as it is a story about incest and its consequences" (p. 18). False memory syndrome is a condition in which a person's identity and interpersonal relationships center on a memory of a traumatic experience that is objectively false but that the person strongly believes occurred.

Insurance companies have become reluctant to insure therapists against malpractice suits relating to recovered memories. The False Memory Syndrome Foundation is a (c)(3) organization founded in March, to seek the reasons for the spread of the false memory syndrome, to work for ways to prevent the spread of the false memory syndrome, and to aid those who were affected by the false memory syndrome and bring their families into reconciliation.

Repressed memory - Wikipedia